Extrinsic Motivation
What is Extrinsic Motivation?
Extrinsic motivation refers to the drive to perform an action or achieve a goal due to external factors, such as rewards, recognition, or the avoidance of punishment. It’s when people are motivated by something outside of themselves rather than internal desires or satisfaction.
In simple terms, if an employee works to earn a bonus, a promotion, or public acknowledgment, they’re being driven by extrinsic motivation. Unlike intrinsic motivation, where individuals are motivated by personal interest or satisfaction, extrinsic motivation relies heavily on external rewards.
Examples of Extrinsic Motivation in the Workplace
- Bonuses and Financial Incentives: Employees often work harder to earn financial rewards like bonuses or raises.
- Recognition and Praise: Receiving praise from managers or colleagues can encourage employees to continue performing well.
- Promotions: The potential for a higher position or career advancement can drive employees to give their best performance.
- Benefits: Health insurance, paid time off , and other employee benefits often motivate people to stay engaged at work.
- Job Security: The need to maintain a steady income and job stability can also be a strong extrinsic motivator.
The Psychology Behind Extrinsic Motivation
So, why does extrinsic motivation work? The answer lies in behavioral psychology.
B.F. Skinner, a renowned psychologist, introduced the idea of operant conditioning. He suggested that behaviors followed by positive reinforcement are more likely to be repeated. That’s basically the blueprint for performance-based rewards in the workplace.
When employees receive something positive for a job well done, their brain makes a connection “Effort equals reward.” This loop can create consistent performance improvements.
How Does Extrinsic Motivation Differ from Intrinsic Motivation?
You may have heard of intrinsic motivation, which is the internal drive to do something for the sheer enjoyment or personal fulfillment it brings. To put it simply:
- Intrinsic Motivation: Driven by personal interest, passion, or satisfaction.
- Extrinsic Motivation: Driven by external rewards, recognition, or avoidance of negative consequences.
| Intrinsic Motivation | Extrinsic Motivation |
|---|---|
| Driven by internal desires | Driven by external factors |
| Results in self-satisfaction and joy | Results in tangible rewards or benefits |
| Examples: Doing something for fun, learning for growth | Examples: Working for a paycheck, striving for a promotion |
Understanding the balance between these two forms of motivation is crucial for HR professionals in shaping organizational culture and employee engagement strategies.
Types of Extrinsic Rewards HR Can Use
Let’s explore the different types of extrinsic rewards and how HR can apply them:
1. Tangible Rewards
These are the most straightforward. Physical or financial incentives like:
- Salary hikes
- Gift cards
- Profit-sharing
- Company merchandise
Pro Tip: Tie rewards directly to measurable KPIs to make them meaningful.
2. Social Recognition
Sometimes, a simple “well done” can go a long way.
- Employee of the month awards
- Shoutouts in meetings
- Social media recognition
- Wall of fame in the office
3. Career Development Opportunities
Rewards that offer long-term benefits:
- Paid certifications
- Sponsoring higher education
- Access to conferences or workshops
This type of motivation adds value both for the employee and the organization.
Pros and Cons of Extrinsic Motivation in HR
Let’s keep it real. Extrinsic motivation is powerful but it’s not perfect. HR needs to weigh the pros and cons before overusing it.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Encourages short-term productivity boosts | Can create a dependency on rewards |
| Creates a results-driven work culture | May reduce intrinsic motivation over time |
| Easy to implement and track | Risk of promoting unhealthy competition |
| Supports performance management strategies | Not always sustainable or scalable |
| Motivates even less engaged employees |
The Role of Extrinsic Motivation in HR
As an HR professional, it’s important to understand the impact of extrinsic motivation on your employees' productivity and job satisfaction. Here’s how it affects various aspects of the workplace:
1. Employee Engagement and Retention
Extrinsic rewards, such as competitive salaries, bonuses, and benefits, are significant factors in keeping employees engaged. When employees see that their efforts are being rewarded in tangible ways, they’re more likely to stay motivated and loyal to the company. It’s no secret that employees are more likely to stay with a company that recognizes their contributions and offers rewards in return.
2. Performance Improvement
Incentives like rewards for achieving targets, performance-based bonuses, or a simple recognition for a job well done can drive employees to perform better. If employees are aware that their hard work will be rewarded, they’re more likely to put in the extra effort to meet or exceed expectations.
3. Goal Alignment
Extrinsic motivators can also help align employees’ goals with the broader goals of the organization. For example, if a company offers a reward for meeting sales targets, it directly encourages employees to work toward achieving these objectives, benefiting both the employee and the company. In this way, extrinsic motivation can create a clear connection between individual performance and company success.
The Benefits of Extrinsic Motivation in HR
While intrinsic motivation plays a vital role in employee satisfaction, extrinsic motivation brings numerous advantages, particularly when aligned with organizational goals. Some of the key benefits include:
1. Increased Productivity
Employees who are motivated by external rewards like bonuses, commissions, or even recognition are more likely to put in their best efforts. It can boost their productivity and help the organization reach its targets more efficiently.
2. Encourages Competition
In a healthy work environment, extrinsic motivation can encourage friendly competition among employees. Offering rewards like “Employee of the Month” or performance bonuses can lead to increased efforts and innovation as employees strive to outperform each other.
3. Enhances Employee Satisfaction
Who doesn’t like being recognized for their hard work? By offering rewards or praise, HR teams can boost employee morale and create a positive work environment. When employees feel appreciated through external rewards, it can increase job satisfaction and reduce turnover rates.
4. Creates a Results-Oriented Culture
Extrinsic motivation helps create a results-oriented culture where employees are focused on achieving measurable outcomes. By incentivizing performance, HR teams can foster a sense of accountability and drive within the organization.
Challenges of Relying Too Much on Extrinsic Motivation
While extrinsic motivation can be an effective tool for driving performance, there are some challenges to be aware of when relying too heavily on it:
1. Over-reliance on External Rewards
Employees might become too dependent on rewards and lose their intrinsic drive for personal growth. If the only motivation comes from external factors, employees may start to perform only for the reward, leading to a lack of engagement when the rewards stop.
2. Risk of Unhealthy Competition
In some cases, extrinsic rewards can create unhealthy competition, where employees prioritize individual success over team collaboration. It’s essential to find the right balance between motivating employees and maintaining a collaborative culture.
3. Diminishing Returns
If rewards are constantly provided for the same level of effort, employees may become accustomed to them, and the impact of the rewards can decrease over time. This phenomenon, known as reward fatigue, can reduce the effectiveness of extrinsic motivation.
When to Use Extrinsic Motivation at Work
Timing is everything. Here’s when extrinsic motivation hits the mark:
- Onboarding phase: Welcome kits, performance bonuses, or milestone rewards keep new hires excited.
- During peak project phases: Extra incentives can push team members during stressful periods.
- Annual performance reviews: Tie promotions or bonuses to review outcomes.
- In sales roles: Commission structures and targets work wonders here.
- For team challenges: Gamification plus rewards = engagement jackpot.
Used wisely, extrinsic motivators can drive a culture of excellence.
How to Use Extrinsic Motivation Effectively in HR?
To make the most of extrinsic motivation, HR professionals need to strike the right balance. Here are some strategies to use extrinsic motivation effectively:
1. Align Rewards with Company Goals
Rewards should be tied to specific company objectives. For example, if a company’s goal is to increase sales, offering sales-based bonuses can align employees’ efforts with organizational priorities.
2. Use Recognition as a Complementary Reward
While financial rewards are great, don't forget about the power of recognition. A public acknowledgment of an employee’s hard work can be just as powerful as a bonus in motivating performance.
3. Offer a Variety of Rewards
Different employees are motivated by different things. Some may appreciate financial incentives, while others may value extra time off or public recognition. Offering a variety of rewards can help keep motivation levels high and cater to different employee preferences.
4. Avoid Overuse of Extrinsic Motivation
While rewards are essential, employees should also feel motivated by their own growth and development. Encourage a balance of extrinsic and intrinsic motivation to keep employees engaged in the long term.
Ready to Motivate Your Team Better? Qandle helps HR teams design smart, data-driven extrinsic motivation programs. Track. Reward. Optimize. Schedule a free demo today and see Qandle in action!
People also look for
Back to Glossary