Joint Employment
Joint Employment is an employment arrangement where two or more employers share control and responsibility over the same worker. While it enables flexible workforce models, it also creates significant legal and compliance risks if misunderstood. For HR leaders and executives, joint employment is not just an HR concept, it's a governance issue that directly impacts liability, payroll, and labor law compliance.
TL;DR
- Joint Employment means multiple employers are legally responsible for the same employee
- Common in staffing, outsourcing, franchising, and gig-based models
- Employers may share liability for wages, benefits, and compliance
- Determined by control, supervision, and economic dependence
- Misclassification can lead to lawsuits, penalties, and reputational damage
What Is Joint Employment?
Joint Employment occurs when an employee is considered to be employed by more than one employer at the same time, based on how work is controlled and managed. Even if only one company issues paychecks, another company may still be legally responsible if it exercises sufficient control over the employee's work.
In the U.S., regulators such as the U.S. Department of Labor evaluate joint employment under laws like the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA). The goal is to prevent businesses from avoiding labor obligations by shifting responsibility to third parties.
For HR teams, the risk lies in assuming 'not on our payroll' equals 'not our responsibility.' In joint employment, that assumption is often wrong.
Common Scenarios Where Joint Employment Applies
Joint employment is more common than many organizations realize, especially in modern workforce models.
Staffing Agencies and Contract Workers
When a staffing agency hires workers but the client company controls schedules, tasks, and supervision, both entities may be joint employers. The agency handles payroll, while the client directs daily work creating shared liability.
Franchising Models
Franchisors that dictate hiring practices, wage policies, or operational controls may be deemed joint employers with franchisees, even if they don't directly employ workers.
Outsourcing and Managed Services
If a company outsources functions like IT support or customer service but still controls performance metrics, work hours, or discipline, joint employment risk increases.
Gig and Platform-Based Work
In platform models, excessive control over pricing, work methods, or availability can blur the line between independent contractors and joint employees.
Pro Tip: The more control your organization exercises over workers even indirectly the higher the joint employment risk.
How Is Joint Employment Determined?
There is no single test, but regulators and courts evaluate economic reality and control.
Key Factors Considered
- Who hires or fires the worker
- Who supervises and directs daily work
- Who sets pay rates and work schedules
- Who provides tools, systems, or training
- Whether the worker is economically dependent on the business
No single factor is decisive. Instead, the total relationship is assessed.
From an HR governance standpoint, documentation, contracts, and actual day-to-day practices must align. Paper agreements alone do not override operational reality.
Joint Employment vs Co-Employment
These terms are often confused but are not identical.
| Aspect | Joint Employment | Co-Employment |
|---|---|---|
| Nature | Legal determination | Contractual arrangement |
| Typical Use | Staffing, franchises | PEO models |
| Liability | Shared by law | Shared by agreement |
| Risk Level | High if unmanaged | More predictable |
In co-employment, responsibilities are clearly divided through a Professional Employer Organization (PEO). In joint employment, liability is imposed by law often unexpectedly.
Why Joint Employment Matters for HR and Leadership
Legal and Financial Liability
If joint employment is established, both employers can be held liable for:
- Unpaid wages or overtime
- Minimum wage violations
- Leave and benefits non-compliance
- Workplace safety issues
This shared liability can result in lawsuits, penalties, and retroactive payments.
Payroll and Benefits Complexity
HR teams must clarify:
- Who tracks hours
- Who pays overtime
- Who provides statutory and voluntary benefits
Misalignment leads to compliance gaps.
Employer Brand Risk
Employees don't differentiate between 'primary' and 'secondary' employers. Poor treatment by one party can damage the brand of the other.
How HR Teams Can Reduce Joint Employment Risk
Clarify Contracts but Go Beyond Them
Contracts should clearly define responsibilities, but HR must ensure daily practices reflect those boundaries.
Limit Direct Control Where Possible
Avoid directly managing schedules, discipline, or compensation for non-payroll workers unless contractually required.
Train Managers
Line managers often create risk unknowingly by treating contractors or agency workers like direct employees.
Audit Workforce Relationships
Regularly review vendor arrangements, staffing models, and role definitions to identify hidden joint employment exposure.
Use Centralized HR Systems
Accurate records of work hours, supervision boundaries, and employment status support compliance and audits.
When Is Joint Employment Unavoidable?
Joint employment is sometimes unavoidable especially in:
- High-volume staffing environments
- Seasonal or project-based labor
- Regulated industries requiring strict operational control
In such cases, the goal is not avoidance but risk-managed compliance through transparency, documentation, and coordination between employers.
Managing shared workforces without clear visibility is risky. Qandle's HRMS helps centralize workforce data, attendance tracking
FAQ's
1. Is joint employment illegal?
No. It is legal, but it creates shared legal responsibilities.
2. Does joint employment require a written agreement?
No. It is determined by actual control and working conditions, not just contracts.
3. Can both employers be sued by an employee?
Yes. Either or both joint employers can be held liable.
4. Is joint employment the same as outsourcing?
Not always. Outsourcing can still result in joint employment if control is shared.
5. How can HR identify joint employment risk early?
By auditing control, supervision, and dependency across non-payroll workers.
6. Does joint employment apply outside the U.S.?
Yes. Many countries have similar doctrines under different legal frameworks.
Back to Glossary